SEND ME TIPS:
The Best Ad Critic In The World™ (™ pending) and a freelance copywriter with 25+ years experience and CLIOs, One Shows, Mobiuses (sp?), ADDYs, ANDYs, and a Bobcat Pin (Cub Scouts).
View my complete profile
posted by Mark Copyranter @ 2:20 PM
I thought the "Pub" Version was quite dull and generic. Once again boring storytelling was mistaken for subtle english humour. It does not always work. And in this case the smarter and loud Devil wins!
Yeah, but it's the same exact creative idea...and who had it first (unless the same people made both spots)?
The pub spot was uploaded on Youtube at the beginning of December, 2010. This new spot came out in April, 2011. No, I don't think the same people made both spots. In the case of the Pub spot, we have an actual agency, The Raft, UK. In the case of the new spot, we've got a bunch of "kids" from Germany. I see no name of an agency mentioned on aotw.
Thanks for the info.
Post a Comment